As a podfic artist I *totally* want to hear the real constructive crit listeners have. I'm not going to pretend it doesn't bother me - I feel mortified for a moment when I get a note like that in my inbox - but in the long run I am glad to get clues as to how I could improve, what my weak spots are, what I can maybe fix. I might never fix some stuff, but I'm glad to *know* so that if I have the time I can go back and re-edit, perhaps, or simply so that I can record better next time, etc.

As a commenter I tend not to give concrit anymore, and that applies across the board from fanfic to fanart and podfic. I might still do it if it is explicitly requested, ot if I'm really good friends with the person, but I shy away from it in general. My life in fandom has made me disinclined to expose myself to reprobation in that particular way. :(

It's sadly a bit inconsistent with my recording position of wanting to be told what's wrong, since I dont actually always advertise that fact - but hey, no one said I had to be consistent, huh?