Man, I just do not get the "yes, you're keeping something from people" argument, and I don't even like podfic! I guess I feel like there's a billion and five fanfics, so so what if someone records something that's podfic only? It's not like that means there's less to read. I like the comparison above about other language fics. I don't feel like something is being withheld from me if someone writes a story in Russian or Spanish and doesn't post an English version of it...