Concrit?

[dodificus]

Constructive criticism, how do people feel about it?

As a recorder, do you want to hear from someone about how you read to fast/left that blooper in at 12:42/had birds screeching in the background*/whatever? Is it helpful or hurtful? Has concrit ever prompted you to make changes to a specific recording or made you change something about the way you record/read in the future?

As a listener, *do* you leave concrit when you feedback? Do you want to but feel stifled or unsure of the reception? Do you think it's rude/pointless/dull to do so?


*I'm pretty sure there are screeching birds in the background of just about everything I've recorded, even though I don't actually own a bird

Comments

[dodificus]

It's funny because you're one of the few people who have explicitly asked me for concrit on their stuff after it's been posted and I can never find anything to say except how awesome it is:P

As a commenter I tend not to give concrit anymore, and that applies across the board from fanfic to fanart and podfic.

Apart from a word misspelled or a missing word or something obvious like that, I rarely feel 'qualified' to leave concrit on fic, I don't know how to articulate what I want to see most of the time. The podfic world is the place where I feel comfortable kind of opening that discussion both as a giver and receiver of concrit.